Should I do a knockdown or a renovation?

October 17, 2022

When it comes to renovating your home, there are two main options: a knockdown rebuild, or a renovation. Both have their pros and cons, and it’s important to weigh up all the factors before making a decision. Here, we take a look at the key differences between a knockdown rebuild and a renovation, to help you decide which is right for you.

Knockdown pros.

1.    A blank canvas.

One of the biggest advantages of a knockdown rebuild is that you start with a blank canvas. This means you can design your dream home from scratch, and have it exactly how you want it.

2.    No time limits.

Another pro of a knockdown rebuild is that there are no time limits. Unlike a renovation, which can often be rushed and have to be completed within a certain time frame, a knockdown rebuild gives you the freedom to take your time and do it right.

3.    Avoid expensive repairs.

If your home is old and in need of major repairs, a knockdown rebuild can often be more cost-effective than a renovation. This is because you won’t have to pay for expensive repairs on an old home, and you can start from scratch with a new build.

4.    Add value to your home.

A well-designed and executed knockdown rebuild can add significant value to your home. This is great if you’re looking to sell in the future, or want to increase the equity in your home.

Knockdown cons.

1.    More expensive.

One of the main disadvantages of a knockdown rebuild is that it can be more expensive than a renovation. This is because you’re essentially starting from scratch, and will need to pay for all new materials, labour, and design costs.

2.    More disruptive.

A knockdown rebuild is also more disruptive than a renovation. This is because you’ll need to move out of your home during the construction process, which can be disruptive and stressful.

3.    More risk.

Another downside of a knockdown rebuild is that there’s more risk involved. This is because you’re starting from scratch, so there’s more chance that something could go wrong during the construction process.

4.    Takes longer.

A knockdown rebuild also takes longer than a renovation. This is because you’re starting from scratch, so the construction process will take longer.

Renovation pros.

1.    Less expensive.

One of the main advantages of a renovation is that it can be less expensive than a knockdown rebuild. This is because you’re not starting from scratch, so you won’t need to pay for all new materials, labour, and design costs.

2.    Less disruptive.

A renovation is also less disruptive than a knockdown rebuild. This is because you can often do it in stages, and you won’t need to move out of your home during the construction process.

3.    More control.

Another pro of a renovation is that you have more control over the process. This is because you can often do it in stages, and you can choose which areas of your home you want to renovate.

4.    Add value to your home.

A well-designed and executed renovation can also add value to your home. This is great if you’re looking to sell in the future, or want to increase the equity in your home.

Renovation cons.

1.    More difficult.

One of the main disadvantages of a renovation is that it can be more difficult than a knockdown rebuild. This is because you’re working with an existing home, so there may be existing problems that you need to account for.

2.    Time limits.

Another downside of a renovation is that there may be time limits. This is because you may need to work around existing problems, and you may need to complete the renovation within a certain time frame.

3.    More risk.

There’s also more risk involved in a renovation than a knockdown rebuild. This is because you’re working with an existing home, so there’s more chance that something could go wrong during the renovation process.

4.    Limited design options.

One final disadvantage of a renovation is that you may have limited design options. This is because you’re working with an existing home, so you may need to work around existing problems.

In conclusion, there are both pros and cons to a knockdown rebuild and a renovation. It’s important to weigh up all the factors before making a decision. If you’re not sure which is right for you, it’s a good idea to speak to a professional builder or architect who can advise you on the best option for your home.

For further insights, take a look at the Chimni Dashboard to get free insights through our property data and analytics.

The Chimni Dashboard

Chimni is the simplest, fastest and most cost-efficient way to analyse postcodes and suburbs across Australia.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.